Ojo Andrew Akinrotimi1*, Ugwemorubong Ujagwun Gabriel2 and Olajumoke Modupe Edun1
1Africa Regional Aquaculture Center/Nigeria Institute for Oceanography P.M.B 5122, Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria
2Department Of Fisheries and Aquatic Environment Faculty of Agriculture, Rivers State University of Science and Technology Port Harcourt Rivers State Nigeria
Received: 01 September, 2015; Accepted: 15 October, 2015; Published: 17 October, 2015
Ojo Andrew Akinrotimi, African Regional Aquaculture Center, Nigerian Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research, Brackish Water Research Station, Buguma, P.M.B. 5122, Rivers State, Nigeria, E-mail:
Akinrotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Edun OM (2015) The Efficacy of Clove Seed Extracts as an Anaesthetic Agent and Its Effect on Haematological Parameters of African Catfish (Clarias Gariepinus). Int J Aquac Fishery Sci 1(2): 042-047. DOI: 10.17352/2455-8400.000008
© 2015 Akinrotimi OA, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Anesthetics; Catfish; Aquaculture; Stress; Clove
Background and Aim: The intensive nature of aquaculture has subjected fish to a number of stressors in the culture medium, anesthetics are widely used to minimize the issue of stress during farming operations and activities. Clove oil is a well known, established and acceptable anesthetics commonly used in aquaculture, this anesthetics is not readily available in developing countries, thus leaving the fish farmers with option of using the locally available plant extracts as anesthetic agent in fish culture. This study therefore assessed the efficacy of aqueous extracts of clove seed and its effect on hematological parameters of the fish.
Methods: A total of 300 Clarias gariepinus comprises of 150 juveniles and 150 adult fish were exposed in triplicates to aqueous extracts of clove seed at concentrations of 5.0, 10.0, 15.0, 20.0 and 25.0mg/l at the rate of 10 fish per tank for both juveniles and adult fish. Induction time (Time taken for the fish to be completely anaesthetized) and recovery time (Time taken for the fish to resume normal swimming) was monitored using stop watch. Also, the effect of the extracts on water quality, survival and hematological parameters of the fish were evaluated using standard methods.
Results: The result obtained revealed that the induction time indicated a size related response with the adult fish significantly (P<0.05) higher than the juveniles at all concentration of exposure. However, reverse was the case in recovery time, as the recover times in juveniles were higher than the adult fish. The survival was 100% in both sizes. Significant alterations were recorded in the haematological variables of the fish, which was more pronounced at higher concentrations of the extracts.
Conclusion: The extract was effective in sedating C.gariepinus and is recommended for use as an aesthetic agent.
The practice of aquaculture has increased tremendously in recent years, making it the fastest growing food producing venture in the world . The intensive nature of aquaculture has subjected farmed fish to a number of stressors which involves various handling procedures from hatchery to the final harvest stage . When stress is induced by these handling procedures in the culture medium, fish react by consuming more energy to compensate for the elevated stress level, this subsequently activate secretion and release of hormones such as catecholamine and cortisol into the system of the fish, these hormones will impact negatively on the maintenance of homeostasis [3-5] and reduced fish performance in the culture medium . Conversely, anesthetics are widely used in aquaculture to minimize the incidence of stress during culture operations and farming activities. The use of anesthetics enhances safety for both fish and farmer during aquaculture operations and management procedures. It allows farm routine practices to be performed with minimum stress for the fish [7-9]. Recently, application of clove oil as anesthetic in farmed fish is on the increase, this is because it is safe, cheap, and nontoxic to the fish and environment. Moreover, it does not require a withdrawal period of 21 days for table fish as other anesthetics of chemical origin such as MS-222, 2 phenoxyethanol, benzocaine, metomidate and quinidine [9,10].
In Nigeria, like other tropical countries of the world, clove plant is commonly cultivated and the leaves used in preparation of drinks, and the seeds are used as food spice in different parts of the country The major component of this seed is eugenol and eugenyl acetate, which are responsible for its sedative properties. It's used as anesthetics in fish culture is not common, thus necessitating the need to evaluate its efficacy as potential anesthetic agent, which can easily be used by the local fish farmers, who cannot accessed the conventional clove oil as a result of its high cost and scarcity.
Hematological parameters are useful in evaluation of internal physiological conditions of fish, this depends on the species of fish, sex, health status and environmental conditions [11-13]. Many authors reported on the use of blood parameters to assess changes associated with stressful conditions, this is because fish is known to be in close association with its immediate environment, and therefore the blood parameters will reveal the internal status of the fish before any outward manifestation of disease [14-16]. Hence, blood can provide substantial diagnostic information in fish, which will be useful for monitoring their health status, in response to application of chemicals in aquaculture. This study therefore, assessed the efficacy of clove seed extracts as a viable anesthetics agent in C. gariepinus and its effect on hematological parameters of the fish.
Materials and Methods
A total of 300 C. gariepinus comprised of 150 juveniles (mean length 26.64cm ± 1.02 SD; mean weight 356.21g ± 1.86 SD) and 150 adults (mean length 52.13cm ± 1.04SD) were collected from the production units, in African Regional Aquaculture Center, Aluu, Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria and transferred immediately in 40L open basin (half filled with water), to the hatchery unit, where they were acclimated to laboratory conditions for seven days. During this period the fish in acclimation tanks were fed with ARAC fish feed (40.0% C.P) at 5% body weight, the water in these holding tanks was renewed every two days .
Dried seeds of clove plant (Syzigium aromaticum) were purchased from open market. Authentication of the plant was done using the keys of Agbaje . The seeds were later ground in the laboratory using 1.5L kitchen blender (model BL 440 Kenwood, Japan). The milled clove seed were sieved into fine powdery form using 0.1µ nylon mesh . The filtered seed were weighed and applied directly in three replicates at concentrations of 5.0, 10.0, 15.0, 20.0 and 25.0 mg/l to the water in 70L experimental tanks filled to 40L mark, the mixture were stirred vigorously to allow homogenous mixing. The fish were individually introduced to the experimental tanks (30 in number) at the rate of 10 fish per tanks in triplicates for both juveniles and adult fish.
Evaluation of induction and recovery time
Eugenol and eugenyl actate compounds were the major constituents of clove seed and were responsible for its anesthetic ability (Table 1). The efficacy of clove seed extracts as anesthetic agents was evaluated by monitoring the induction time (Time taken for the fish to get sedated) using stop watch according to the methods of Coyle et al. , (Table 2). The induction time was obtained when fish lost equilibrium, showed slow opercula movement, and did not react to stimuli when touched. These correspond to 4 stages of anesthesia in fish as described by Coyle et al. . After anesthesia, fish was individually removed from the experimental tanks by using a scoop net and transfer into other tanks containing clean water tank without anesthetics, to determine the recovery time. The recovery time (time taken for the fish to resume normal swimming) was equally taken with stop watch and recorded. Recovery was considered as complete; when after transfer of the fish to clean water, the fish fully regained its equilibrium and resume normal swimming.
Assessment of water quality and blood parameters
During the study, some water quality parameters such as temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, nitrite, ammonia and sulphide were evaluated in the experimental tanks using the method of APHA . After the fish was immobilized with the clove seed extracts, 2ml of blood was collected from the caudal peduncle using separate heparinized disposable syringes into sample bottles containing 0.5mg ethylate diamine tetracetic acid (EDTA) as anticoagulant. Various hematological parameters were evaluated thus: Hemoglobin (Hb) concentration was done using cyanmethemoglobin method  and packed cell volume (PCV) was evaluated using microhaematocrit method of Snieszko . The Red Blood cell (RBC) was estimated using haemocytometer (Improved Neubauer Weber, Scientific ltd) according to Wintrobe . Also, the total white Blood cell counts (WBC) was evaluated with an improved Neubauer Haemocytometer using shaw's diluting fluid . Differential counts: lymphocytes, monocytes and neutrophils were done on blood film stained with May Grumwald-Giemsa stain. Thromobcytes Count was done by Ress and Ecker method . The Red blood cell indices which include: mean corpuscular haemoglobin concentration (MCHC), mean corpuscular haemoglobin (MCH) and mean corpuscular volume (MCV) were calculated using the formula described by Dacie and Lewis .
The experiments were conducted with ethical standards in handling of the experimental animals. The fish used were handled with care, which involved high consideration of standard fish rearing and good facilities. There was no ethical issues or reservations encountered during the experiment.
The data obtained were collated and analyzed statistically by one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and differences among means were determined by Tuckey's multiple comparison tests by SPSS Software for determining the significance of change from the control.
The water quality parameters in the experimental tanks of the fish exposed to clove seed extracts revealed that the parameters were within the same range, with no significant variation comparable to the control (Table 3). Stages of induction time in juveniles adult stages of C.gariepinus exposed to various concentrations of clove seed extracts are presented in Tables 4, 5. The various stages of induction time which include slow swimming, loss of equilibrium, opercula movement and loss of movement reduced significantly (P<0.05) as the concentrations of the clove extracts increased. (Tables 4, 5). Various stages of recovery time in C.gariepinus and adult size of the fish are shown in Tables 6, 7. The various stages of recovery time which include: reappearance of opercula balance, recovery of equilibrium and resumption of normal swimming increased significantly (P<0.05) with increasing concentration of the clove seed extracts (Tables 6, 7).
The induction time both juvenile and adult size of C.gariepinus exposed to clove seed extracts indicated a size related response, with the induction time in the adult consistently higher than the juveniles at all concentrations of exposure (Table 8). However, a reverse situation in recovery time, where the juveniles were observed to be significantly (p<0.05) higher than the adult sizes. Interestingly, the survival was 100% in both sizes, as no mortality was recorded in all concentrations of clove powder extracts (Table 8).
Changes in heamatological variables exposed to clove seed extracts in both juveniles and adult size of C.gariepinus are presented in Table 9 and 10 respectively. Significant reduction (p<0.05) were recorded in the values of PCV, Hb, RBC, OCC, Thrombocytes and Lymphocytes, the reduction was more noticeable in thrombocytes in adult fish (Table 9) which reduced from 193.35 ± 7.21% to 148.01 ± 7.21. Moreover, WBC and some differential counts such as MCV also increased as the concentration of the clove extracts increased. This was more pronounced in the juvenile fish (Table 9) than in the adult (Table 10). There was no definite trend, in the response or MCH and MCHC, as all the values were within the same range in both size groups.
Induction time is the time taken for the fish to be sedated and it is usually depends on the concentration of the anaesthetics . The results in this study showed that increasing concentrations of the clove seed extracts significantly reduced with induction time. This was in line with the reports of Akinrotimi et al. , in two species of mullets, Liza falcipinis and Liza grandisquamis exposed to clove seed extracts, but differs from that of Akinrotimi et al. , in exposure of C.gariepinus to aqueous extracts of Indian almond tree leaf, which required a higher concentration to induce the fish. This difference could be as a result of variations in biological and environmental factors that influences the efficacy of botanicals as an anesthetic agent. Anesthesia is influenced by the concentration of the anesthetic in the central nervous system (CNS) of the organism. Therefore, in the present investigation, the shorter induction time taken to sedate the experimental fish C.gariepinus, with increased concentration of the clove extracts, may be attributed to the accumulation of the active ingredients such as eugenol and eugenyl acetate in the body system of the fish which impaired the activity of CNS at a much faster rate. Conversely, biological factors such as age, species, life stage, size, lipid content body condition and disease status, have been reported by many authors to have profound effect on metabolic rate and consequently' the pharmacokinetics of the anesthetic agents [32-34]. Similarly, environmental indices namely, salinity, dissolved oxygen and pH could affect the anesthetic rate as well as its uptake across the gills . The induction time in this study were found to be lower in juveniles' fish when compared to adult fish. This agrees with the findings of Hseu et al. , in gold lined sea bream, (Sparus sarba) and that of Pawar et al. , in yellow horse (Hippocampus kuda). The shorter induction time in juvenile fish when compared to adult may be due to small body size and reduced surface area of the gill in juvenile fish .
The recovery time was directly proportional to increasing concentration of the extracts. In this study the adult fish recover faster from the effects of the anesthetics than the juveniles. A similar result was observed in redline torpedo fish (Sahyadria denisonii) exposed to 2 - phenoxy ethanol  contrary view was recorded by Mylonass et al. , in Dicentrarchus labrax and Sparus aurata treated with clove oil, such differences may be related to variation in species, and physiological status of the fish . In the present study where different concentrations of the anesthetics was used to tranquilized the fish, the differences in recovery time observed, may be explained by the fact that more of the active ingredients of the anesthetic extracts accumulated in the CNS of the fish at higher concentrations, thus suppressing the activity of the CNS to a greater degree than at lower concentrations and consequently prolonging the recovery time of the fish from the effects of anesthetics.
Haematological parameters are closely related to fish response to adverse environmental conditions . In this study significant variations were observed at higher concentrations (150 and 200 mg/l) of the clove extracts. This result support the findings of Prashar et al. , in roach, (Rutilus rutilus) exposed to clove powder. These alterations in blood variables may be due to cytotoxicity of clove extracts at higher concentrations. These caused a significant decrease in red blood cell, hemoglobin and PCV of the fish at higher concentrations of the extracts. This reduction may be attributed to hemolysis which results in haemodilution, a means of diluting the haemoconcentration of the extracts thus reducing the effect of the chemicals in its system. The white blood cells in experimental fish increased notably at higher concentrations of the clove seed extracts. Thus, increasing or decreasing numbers of white blood cells are normal reaction on the exposure of fish to chemical irritants. In the present investigation, the increase in WBC (leukocytosis) may have resulted from the excitation of defense mechanism of the fish to counter the effect of the higher concentrations of the extracts. Abdolazizi et al. , in exposure of gold fish (Carassius auratus) to clove oil did not report any alteration in the haematological variables of the fish, this may be due to the exposure of fish to ideal (safe) concentrations of clove. In this study, the ideal concentration is 100mg/l. According to Stetter , an ideal concentration for an anesthetic agent should induce a rapid induction time of 3-5 minutes and recovery time of 5 to 10 minutes, with little or no effects on its haematological variables.
Based on the findings of this study, aqueous extracts from clove seed could effectively be used to sedate fish for different farm operations in aquaculture. This study further revealed that the extracts could be safely applied at 100.0 mg/l, which is sufficient to anaesthetize the fish with little or no changes on its heamatological parameters.
- Subasinghe R (2005) State of world aquaculture FAO, Fisheries and Aquaculture Department, Rome.
- Akirotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Orokota OO (2013) Changes in enzyme activities of Clarias gariepinus brood fish exposed to anaesthetic metomidate. Applied. Ecol and Env Sci 1: 37-40.
- Barton BA, Iwamu GK (1991) Physiological changes in fish from stress in aquaculture with emphasis on the response and affects of corticosteroids. Annual Rev. Fish Dis 1: 3.6.
- Pickering AD (1993) Growth and stress in fish production. Aquaculture 111: 51-63.
- Min Ouk Park, Woo June Hur, Soo-Yeon Im, Dong-Won Seol, Jinhwan Lee, et al. (2008) Anesthetic efficacy and physiological responses to clove oil anaesthetized help grouper Epinephelus bruneus. Aquacult Res 39: 877- 884.
- Akinrotimi OA, Agokei EO, Aranyo AA (2012) Changes in haemaological parameters of Tilapia guineensis exposed to different salinity levels. J Env Eng Tech 1: 4-12.
- King WU, Hooper B, Hillsgrove S, Benton C et al (2005) The use of clove oil metominade tricaine and phenoxy ethanol for inducing anesthetics and their effect on the cortisol stress response in black sea bass. Aquac. Res 36: 1442-1449.
- Akinrotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Deekae SN (2014) Anaesthetic efficacy of sodium bicarbonate and its effects on the blood parameters of African catfish Clarias gariepinus (Burchell, 1822). Journal of Aquatic sciences 29: 233-246.
- Weber RA, Peleteriro JB, Garcia Martin L0, Aldegunde B (2009) The efficacy of 2 – phenoxy ethanol, metomidate clove oil and MS 222 as anaesthetics agents in the Senegalese sole. Aqua 288: 147-150.
- Keene JL, Noakes DLG, Moceia RD, Soto CG (1998) The efficacy of clove oil as an anesthetic for rainbow trout. Aqua Res 29: 84-101.
- Hrubec TC, Smith SA, Robertson JL (2001) Age related in haematology and chemistry values of hybrid stripped bass Morone saxatilis. Vet Clin Pathol 30: 8-15.
- Akinrotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Anyanwu PE, Anyanwu AO (2007) Influence of sex, acclimation methods and period on haematology of sarotherodon melanotheron. Res. J Biol Sci 2: 348-352.
- George RK, Malini NA, Rajasree D (2015) Effects of acclimation on the haematological indices of different groups of fresh water teleosts. J Appl Sci Nat Sci 7: 5-9.
- Musa SO, Omeregie E (1999) Haematological changes in the mud fish clarias gariepinus exposed to malachite green. J Aqult Sci 14: 37-47.
- Okechukwu EO, Ansa J, Balogun JK (2007) Effects of acute nominal doses chlornyrifos – ethyl on some haematological indixes of African catfish, (Clarias gariepinus). J Fish Int 2: 190-194.
- Akinrotimi OA, Uedeme-Naa B, Agokei EO (2010) Effects Of Acclimation On Haematological Parameters Of Tilapia guineensis (Bleeker, 1862). Sci World J 5: 1-4.
- Akinrotimi OA, Abu OMG, Agokei EO, Uedeme-Naa B (2010) Effects of direct transfer to fresh water on the haematological parameters of Tilapia guineensis Bleeker, 1862. Anim Res Int 7: 1199-1205.
- Agbaje EO (2008) Gastrointestinal effects of Syzigium aromaticum (L) Merr. & Perry (Myrtaceae) in animal models. Nig Quant J Hosp Med 18: 137-141.
- Akinrotimi OA (2014) Comparative efficacy of selected synthetic and organic anaesthetics in Clarias gariepinus. ph.D Doctoral Degree Thesis. Rivers State University of Science and Technology, Port Harcourt, Nigeria. 286.
- Coyle SD, Durborow RM, Tidwell HJ (2004) Anesthetics in Aquaculture. Southern Relational Aquaculture center No 3900: 6.
- APHA (1998) Standard methods for the examination of water and waste water (17th Edition) American Public Health Association, Washington 1189.
- Brown BA (1980) Haematology Principle and Procedure (3rd Edition) Lea and Fabinger, Philadelphia USA.
- Stanislas Francis SNIESZKO (1960) Micro haematocrit as a tool in fisheries management. Special scientific report – fisheries No. 314.US Department International Fish and Fishries Wildlife Special Science Report 15.
- Wintrobe MM (1978) Clinical Haematology. H Kimpton, London, UK.
- Miale JB (1982) Laboratory Medicine Haematology (6h edition). The CV Musby Publishing London.
- Seiverd CE (1964) Haematology for Medical Technologists. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia USA 39: 867.
- Dacie JV, Lewis SM (2001) Practical Harmatology (9th edition), Church Hill Livingstone London.
- Nassar MI, Gaara AH, El-Ghorab A.H, Farray ARH, Shen H, et al. (2007) Chemical constituents of clove Syzigium aromaticum and their antioxidant activity. Rev Lat Quim 35: 47-57.
- Akinrotimi OA, Edun OM, Mebe ED (2013) Effects of clove seed as anesthetic agent in two species of agrey mullets Liza falcipinnis and Liza grandisquamis. J Aquat Sci 1: 7-10.
- Akinrotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Deckae SN (2014) Investigation on the potential of Indian almond three (Terminalia catappa) leaf extracts as anesthetic agent in African catfish (Clarias gariepinus). J Aquat Sci 29: 223-231.
- Agokei OE, Adebisi AA (2010) Tobacco as an anesthetic in fish handling procedures. J Med Plant Res 4: 1396-1399.
- Anju TD, Solomon SG, Chcikyula JO (2015) Effects of Aqueous leaf extract of Tephropsia vogeli as a tranquilizer on the African catfish Heterobrabchus longifilis. Am J Res Comm 3: 45-59.
- Metin S, Didinen IB, Kubilay A, Aker 1 (2015) Determination of Anesthetic effects of some medicinal plants on rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). J Limn Fresh Water Fish Res 1: 37-42.
- Mylonas CC, Cardinaletti G, Sigelaki I, Polzonettimagni A (2005) Comparative efficacy of clove oil and 2 phenoxyethanol as anaesthesic, in aquaculture of European sea bass of different temperature. Aqua 246: 467-481.
- Hseu JR, Yeh SL, Ch YT, Ting YY (1998) Comparison of efficacy of five anesthetic gold lined sea bream Sparus sarba. Acta Zool 9: 35 -41.
- Pawar HB, Sanaye SU, Srapada RA, Harish V, et al. (2011) Comparative efficacy of four anesthetics agents in the yellow sea horse, Hippo campus kuda (Blacker 1852). Aquacult 311: 155-161.
- Akinrotimi OA, Gabriel UU, Erondu ES (2012) Induction and recovery times in three sizes of Clarias gariepinus exposed to anesthetic methane sulfonate (MS – 222). Nig J Fish 9: 560-565.
- Varkey A.M, Sajevan S (2014) Efficacy of 2-phenoxycthanol as an anesthetic for adult redline torpeo fish Sahyadria denisonii (Day 1865). Int J Zool 31: 31-36.
- Ross LG, Ross B (1999) Anesthetic and Sedative Techniques for Aquatic Animals. 2nd ed. Blackwell Science, Oxford, UK. 15.
- Akinrotimi OA, Abu OMG, Bekibele DO, Uedene – Naa, B, Aranyo AA (2010) Haematological characteristics of Tilapia guineensis from Buguma Creek, Niger Delta, Nigeria. Elect J Env Agric Food Chem 9: 1415-1422.
- Prashar A, Locke IC, Evans CS (2006) Cytotoxicity of clove (Syzygium aromaticum) oil and its major components to human skin cells. Cell Prolif 39: 241-248.
- Abdolazizi S, Naghdi N, Kamaya B (2011) Effect of clove oil as an anesthetic on some haematological parameters of Carassius auratus. Aquat Res Dev 2: 1-3.
- Stetter MD (2001) Fish and amphibian anesthesia. Vet Clin. North Amer Exot Anim Pract 4: 69-82.