ISSN: 2641-2969
Annals of Environmental Science and Toxicology
Research Article       Open pjestcess      Peer-Reviewed

Seasonal Changes of Microbial Load in Some Sea Foods from Buguma and Ekerekana Creeks, Niger Delta, Nigeria

Olajunmoke Modupe Edun1, Ojo Andrew Akinrotimi1* and Oluwaseun Opeyemi Makinde2

1African Regional Aquaculture Center of Nigeria Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research Buguma, Nigeria
2Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Science, University of Port Harcourt, Nigeria
*Corresponding author: Ojo Andrew Akinrotimi, 2African Regional Aquaculture Center of Nigeria Institute for Oceanography And Marine Research Buguma, P.M.B 5122 Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria, E-mail: ojoakinrotimi@yahoo.com
Received: 01 September, 2015 | Accepted: 04 January, 2016 | Published: 05 January, 2016

Cite this as

Edun OM, Akinrotimi OA, Makinde OO (2016) Seasonal Changes of Microbial Load in Some Sea Foods from Buguma and Ekerekana Creeks, Niger Delta, Nigeria. Ann Environ Sci Toxicol 1(1): 001-007. DOI: 10.17352/pjest.000001

Background and Aim: Niger delta environment has been exposed to organic and inorganic contaminants from industries and domestic wastes, thereby enhancing the capacity of the ecosystem into harboring a sizeable population of microorganisms. Most of these microorganisms are found in the water column, bottom sediment and water film, resulting in their elevated levels in seafood. Proper understanding of the transfer of microorganisms through the food web is essential to predict the exposure of seafood consumers to possible health consequences associated with its consumption in the coastal areas. Hence, the present study examines the microbial content of some sea foods such as: periwinkle (Tympanotonus fuscatus); mudskipper (Periophthalmus papilio); mullets (Liza falcipinis) Oyster (?Crassotrea gasar) and water from Ekerekana and Buguma creeks, in the Niger delta, Nigeria.

Methods: Seasonal variations in microbial content in some seafood namely: Periwinkle (T. fuscatus); mudskipper (P. papilio); mullet (L. falcipinnis) and Oyster (C. gasar) from Ekerekana and Buguma creeks, Niger delta, Nigeria were assessed. The sea foods were sampled monthly from both creeks for a period of eight months. Standard methods were employed in the evaluation of microbial load in each species.

Results: The result indicated that the microorganisms isolated: total heterotrophic bacteria count, total vibro count; and total coliform count were more predominant in the wet season when compared to dry season months. Total coliform count bacteria exhibited some measure of elevation in the dry season months, an indication that they can be prevalent in both seasons depending on the type of human activities that is prevalent in the area.

Conclusion: This study has shown that industrial and domestic wastes discharged into Ekerekana and Buguma creek resulted in high concentrations of pollutants in the water body, which promotes the growth of microorganisms in the water column and sea foods, this may pose a health hazard to humans as a final consumer of these organisms There is therefore the need to formulate appropriate policies and regulations for safeguarding the ecosystem from adding undesirable microbial population.

Introduction

Seafood constitutes an important food component for a large proportion of world population especially those living in coastal areas [1,2]. In recent years, the Niger delta, environment have been exposed to organic and inorganic contaminants from industries and domestic wastes, especially oil related activities which are predominant in the region, thereby enhancing the capacity of the ecosystem into harboring a sizeable population of microorganisms [3]. The continuous release of these pollutants has resulted in an enriched microbial community. These microbes often find surfaces or organs of aquatic organisms for colonization [4]. Hayat et al. [5], noted that the number and type of microorganisms found on freshly caught seafood are influenced by location, season and rate of environmental pollution.

Bacterial species of enteric origin namely; Bacillus spp. E. coli, Shigella spp. Staphylococcus aureus and Listeria monocytogenes can be isolated from coastal water, as a result of human activities, such as improper waste disposal which include human, domestic and industrial wastes [6,7]. Most of these bacterial organisms are usually isolated from waters which contain fecal materials [8-10]. Pathogenic bacteria in marine waters are most abundant in the sediments, they can also be found on the surface film, as well as in the water column [11]. As a result, fin and shell fishes found in marine environment often show elevated levels of these bacteria, which can cause disease in fish as well as human host that consume them. In most Niger delta communities, periwinkle, oyster, mullets and mudskipper are delicacies, they are in high demand among the populace living in these areas [12,13].

However, proper understanding of the transfer of microorganisms through the food web is essential to predict the exposure of consumers of this seafood to possible health consequences associated with their consumption. A large proportion of people living in rural and urban communities of Niger delta consume on regular basis sea foods harvested from the rivers, creeks and estuaries, laden with history of pollution consequent of domestic and industrial activities. Oysters and periwinkles are filter – feeding organisms capable of accumulating microorganisms in high concentrations. These organisms filter the surrounding water and consequently assimilate all the contaminants present in these environments. Consumers of these sea foods are therefore exposed to microbial and chemical pollutants in the ecosystem. Conversely, mudskipper and mullets are prominent aquatic animals found in brackish water zone of the Niger delta. They are particularly adapted to coastal environments, where they are widely consumed as food fish, because of their position in the food chain, they can equally accumulate microorganisms from their immediate environment. Hence the present study examines the seasonal variation in microbial content of some sea foods such as: periwinkle (T.fuscatus), mudskipper (P.papilio), mullets (L. falcipinis), Oyster (C.gasar) and water from Ekerekakana and Buguma creeks, in Niger delta, Nigeria.

Materials and Methods Study Area

The study was carried out in Ekerekana and Buguma creeks, Niger delta, Nigeria. Ekerekana creek is located in Okrika local Government Area or Rivers State, Nigeria and lies between longitude 700 and 601E and latitude 400 and 501N. While Buguma creek is located in Asari Toru local Government area of the state. It is situated between longitude 60471E and latitude 400 591N (Figure 1).

Sampling period

The sampling was carried out bimonthly between July 2012 and February 2013; consisting of four wet season months (July-October) and four dry season months (November February).

Collection of samples

The different species used in the study were sampled from the creeks based on their life cycle, feeding and behavioural pattern. These species were chosen based on their availability all year round. Ten samples of each specimen were collected in each of the sampling months. The periwinkles (T. fuscatus) were handpicked from the sediment in the creeks at low tide. The oysters (C. gasar) were collected with the aid of knife from the roots of the mangroves during low tide. Specially designed traps were used in the collection of mudskipper (P.papilio), while mullets Liza falcipinnis were collected from the creeks using a seine net. They were kept in a sterile isothermal container and transported to the laboratory for microbiological analysis. At the laboratory, these samples were extensively washed and rinsed with normal saline solution to remove dirt, debris and surface contaminants. The edible parts of oysters were removed from the shell with a sterilized sharp knife, while that of periwinkle was removed with the aid of a specially fabricated sterile needle. The fleshy part of mullets and mudskippers were cut with sterilized knife. These samples were transferred separately one at a time to a sterile blender for homogenization and serial dilution.

Water samples were collected monthly with sterile plastic containers from both creeks, in all sampling months. The containers were rinsed three times with the water samples to be collected at the site before the collection was made. The water and the sea foods were later transferred to the laboratory for microbiological analysis.

Microbiological analysis

Total hetorotrophic bacteria count; Total vibrio count; Total Salmonella/ Shegella count and Total Coliform count were analysed in water and seafood samples namely periwinkle, oyster, mudskipper and mullets.

Samples of the seafood (the fleshy edible part) were hygienically transferred to a sterile stomacher (Model BA 6021, Seward Medical, UK) according to the method described by Aluyi et al. [14]. This was later homogenized, using 225ml sterile 0.1% peptone water for a period of two minutes. Serially, tenfold dilution up to 105 of the homogenates were made by transferring 1ml of fresh sterile dilutors to plates of surface-dried Nutrient Agar for total bacteria count and Salmonella-Shigellae Agar for salmonella count. All plates were incubated at 370C for 48 hours. In analysis of total coliform, the 5-tube MPN (Most Probable Numbers) methods described by Gerhardt et al. [15], was employed. The tubes for total coliforms were incubated at 370 C for 24 hours. Evaluation of bacterial number was done by plant count following the methods described by APHA [16].

Enumeration of Vibrio spp . was done by using the medium Thiosulphate citrate bile salt agar (TCBS). Aliquot (0.1ml) each of water sample and each of the seafood was pipette aseptically into TCBS plates in triplicates and spread with a sterile glass rod. The Vibrio spp . was later enumerated using standard microbiological techniques [17].

Data analysis

The data generated from the study was collated and analyzed in each of the seafood and water samples from both creeks and were presented in tabular form and student t-test was used to show differences between season and sample sites.

Results

The results of population densities of colony forming unit’s per-millimeter of Total Heterotrophic bacteria (THB) count that are found in water and seafood samples in the wet and the dry season months of study are presented in Table 1. The result indicated that the values of THB in Ekerekana creek were significantly (p<0.001) higher than that of the Buguma creek in both wet and dry season months. The overall average values of THB (5.5x105 cfu/ml) in wet season were significantly (p<0.005) higher than the value of 3.5x105 cfu/ml obtained in the dry season months. The average values of total vibrio count (TVC) in the sampled water and seafood from Ekerekana creek was significantly (p<0.005) higher than that of Buguma creek in wet and dry season respectively (Table 2). The overall average values (3.46x105 cfu/ml) in wet season were significantly higher (p<0.0001) than the average values (1.95x105 cfu/ml) obtained during the dry season. The seasonal variation in the population of Total Shigella counts (TSC) in water and sea foods from Ekerekana and Buguma creeks is presented in Table 3. During the wet season, the average value (4.58x105 cfu/ml) of TSC in Ekerekena creek was significantly (p<0.05) higher than the average value (2.65x105) obtained in Buguma creek. Conversely, the same trend was equally observed during the dry season, with the average value of TSC (3.51x105 cfu/ml) in Ekerekana creek which was significantly (p<0.005) higher than the value of 2.78x105 cfu/ml recorded in Buguma creek. The overall average value of TSC in the wet season was significantly (p<0.05) higher than the dry season months. The values of Total coliform in Ekerekana creek were significantly (p<0.005) higher than that of the Buguma creek in both wet and dry season months. The overall average of the total coliform count between dry and wet seasons were almost within the same range with no significant difference (p>0.05) between the wet and dry season months (Table 4).

Discussion

In the two creeks studied in this work, the seafood analyzed contains more bacteria species in the wet season months (July – October) than the dry season months (November – February). This may be due to increase in concentration of bacterial flora in the surrounding water, as fish and shell fishes have a tremendous ability to concentrate bacteria from their immediate surrounding waters [18]. In the present study, Vibrio spp isolated in the sea foods is more predominant in Ekerekana creek compared to Buguma creek during the study months. This is similar to the results of Yang et al. [19], when comparing two coastal areas of Eastern China. This result is also comparable with that of Zimmerman et al. [20], in the Gulf of Mexico waters. Vibiro species were also isolated from Buguma, but at lower concentrations, this supports the findings of Omenwa et al. [21], in the same creek. This may be due to human activities, such as bathing, defecation by the local populace, coupled with waste from cottage industries, which are common phenomenon in the area. Conversely, Winfield and Groisman [22], reported that increased level of human activities could bring about the elevation of organic matter resulting in high microbial load in the water, therefore high microbial population in an aquatic environment, is an indication of the input of microorganisms from domestic and industrial sources consequent of human activities.

Salmonella spp is one of the most important food-borne pathogens and are indicators of sewage contamination and it is found to be associated with a number of non-human hosts such as reptiles [23]. This bacteria species has been reported to survive and persist in the aquatic environment and has been detected in seafood in different creeks of Niger Delta [24] and causes new born meningitis and infantile diarrhoea [24]. In addition, Staphylococcus aureus was isolated in seafood sampled from Ekerekana creek, this is in agreement with that reported by Okonko et al. [25], while comparing the microbial quality of sea foods from two different areas.

The seasonal changes observed in the various microbial groups in both creeks could be as a result of the influence of the physico-chemical properties and human activities. Earlier findings have shown slightly elevated levels of faecal Coliforms in creeks during the wet season than dry season [26], these observations were attributed to the effects of low salinity, high turbidity and low temperatures which are typical of wet season months [27].

The total heterotrophic bacteria (THB), Total Vibrio counts, (TVB) and Total Salmonella and Shigella count (TSC) of the creeks revealed higher counts in the wet months (July to October) than the dry season months (November to December). This observation may be due to more favourable physical and chemical conditions such as No3-, S042, pH and temperature occasioned by allochthonus materials from the sampling area of the creek during the season [28]. The increase in the bacterial population is attributed to the stimulatory effect of additional carbon and energy sources in the form of effluents, and crude oil, which leads to an enrichments of the oil degrading microbial population, this is made possible by hydrocarbon utilizing bacteria [29]. Also, Eze [30], observed a similar trend in inland water in Port Harcourt. More hydrocarbon utilizing bacteria (HUB) counts were recorded in the wet season than the dry season. This result is in tandem with the higher concentrations of THC recorded in these creeks, during the wet season, confirming that these organisms require hydrocarbons as their sole source of energy [31]. It should be noted that microorganisms, especially bacteria play a major role in hydrocarbon degradation in aquatic environments. The presence of these hydrocarbon degraders in the river might result in commensality or complimentary degradations in the aquatic ecosystem [32]. Also, Njoku et al. [34], noted that apart from the natural input of carbon into aquatic habitats, hydrocarbon compounds can enter the ecosystem through human activities, such as transportation and oil explorative activities.

However, the total coliform count did not change as such between both seasons and in both creeks. This could be attributed to the toxic effects of hydrocarbons on organisms which at certain concentrations could also be either inhibitory on stimulatory in different conditions [33,34]. Although some hydrocarbon organism are known to contain plasmids with the relevant genes for the degradation of different hydrocarbons [34].

Moreover, there are occasional rainfalls in the coast of Niger delta in the dry season months, whose run-off carries some load of debris, faecal and organic matter into the creeks resulting in higher values of total coliform count bacteria as recorded in this study. Earlier studies by different authors suggests that rainfall pattern in a particular zone may influence the bacteria invertebrate interactions in the aquatic environment, possibly by changing the concentration of bacteria organisms in surface waters, feeding habits of the aquatic organisms and depuration dynamics [35-37].

Conclusion

This study has shown that the total heterotrophic bacteria count total Vibro count; and total coliform count were more predominant in the wet season compared to dry season months, total coliform count bacteria exhibited some measure of elevation in the dry season months an indication that they can be prevalent in both seasons depending on the type of human activities that is prevalent in the area. Also, these isolated organisms were more in population in Ekerekana creek compared to Buguma creek. This may have resulted from industrial and domestic wastes discharged into Ekerekana and Buguma creeks which resulted in the presence of high concentrations of pollutants in the water body. The complex combination of toxic substances that is simultaneously present in the environment may act synergistically and therefore impose a higher toxicity burden on the ecosystem by stimulating and promoting growth of microorganisms in the water column and sea foods such as periwinkle, oyster, mullet and mudskippers which may pose a health hazard to humans as a final consumer of these organisms. Also, continued discharge of improperly treated effluent may further compound the worsening environmental problem of the creek and cause ecological imbalance of the Niger Delta basin. There is therefore the need to formulate appropriate policies and regulations for safeguarding the ecosystem from adding undesirable microbial population.

  1. Edema MO, Omemu AM, Bankole MO (2005) Microbiological safety and quality of ready to eat food in Nigeria. In the proceedings of the 29th Annual Conference and General Meeting (Abeokuta 2005) on microbes as agent of sustainable development organized by Nigerian Society for Microbiology (NSNA), University of Agriculture, Abeokuta from 6-10th November 1181.
  2. Akinrotimi OA, Edun OM, Uka U, Owhonda KN (2013) Public perception of mudskipper consumption in some fishing communities of Rivers State, Nigeria. Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science 8: 208-212 .
  3. Akinrotimi OA, Edun, OM, Makinde OO (2015) Seasonal variation of heavy metals in selected sea foods from Buguma and Ekerakana creeks, Niger delta. International Journal of Innovative Studies in Aquatic Biology and fisheries 1: 46-53 .
  4. Mahalarmi B, Revathy, K, Raghunathan, C, Anjalai, K, Anandan, S (2013) Distribution of microbial population associated with crabs from Ennore seacoast Bay of Bengal north east coast of India. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences 2: 290-305 .
  5. Hayat SM, Javed B, Razzaq S (2007) growth performance of metal stressed major carps viz. catla catla, Labeo rohita and Cirrhina mrigala reared under semi-intensive culture system. Pakistan Vet J27: 812 .
  6. Lynch M, Painter J, Woodruff R, Braden C; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2006) Surveillance for foodborne-disease outbreaks –United State, 1998 – 2002. MMWR Surveill Summ 55: 1-42 .
  7. Odu NN, Obafemi A, Njoku, HO (2010) Comparative assessment of bacteriological quality and proximate composition of laboratory shucked and traditionally shucked tropical periwinkle Tympanotonos fuscatus. Scientia Africana 9: 140-149.
  8. Su YC, Liu C (2007) Vibrio parahemolyticus a concern of seafood safety. Food Microbiol 24: 549-558 .
  9. Edun OM, Akinrotimi OA (2011) Study of consumer consumption behaviour for mangroves Oyster (Crassostrea gasar) in some coastal communities of Rives State, Nigeria. International Journal of Life Sciences 1: 10-21 .
  10. Adeleye IA, Daniels FV, Enyinnia VA (2010) Characterization and Pathogenicity of Vibrio spp. Comtaining Seafoods in Lagos, Nigeria. Internet Journal of Food Safety 12: 1-9 .
  11. Bassey SC, Ofem OE, Essien NM, Eteng MU (2014) Comparative microbial evaluation of two edible seafood P.palludosa (Apple Snail) and E.radiata (Clam) to ascertain their consumption safety. Journal Nutrition and food Sciences 4: 1-4 .
  12. Akinrotimi OA, Abu OMG, Ansa EJ, Edun OM, George OS (2009) Haematological responses of Tilapia guineensis to acute stress. International Journal of National and Applied Sciences 5: 338-343 .
  13. Akinrotimi OA, Onunkwo DN, Cliffe, PT, Anyanwu PE, Orokotan OO (2007) The role of fish in the nutrition and livelihoods of families in Niger delta, Nigeria. International Journal of Tropical Agriculture and Food Systems 1: 344-351 .
  14. Aluyi HSA, Ekhaise FO and Adelusi DM (2006) Effect of human activities and oil pollution on the microbiological and physicochemical quality of Udu River, Warri, Nigeria. Journal of Applied Sciences 6:1214-1219 .
  15. Gehardt P, Murray EGR, Wood AW and Krieg RN (1994) Methods for General and Molecular Bacteriology. ASM. Press. Washington DC, USA .
  16. American Public Health Association (1998) Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater. 20th Ed., American Public Health Association New York, USA .
  17. BAM (1998) Bacteriological Analytical Manual .
  18. D Kar, P Sur, SK Mandal, T Saha, RK Kole (2008) Assessment of heavy metals in surface waters. Int J Environ Sci Tech 5: 119-124 .
  19. Yang Z, Jiao X, Zhou G, Cao W, Gu R (2008) Isolation molecular characterization of Vibrio paraheamopyticus from fresh, low temperature preserved, dried and salted seafood products in two coastal areas of eastern China. International of Food Microbiology 125: 279-285 .
  20. Zimmerman AM, Depaola, A, Bowers, JC, Grmes, DJ (2007) Variability of total and Pathogenic of Vibrios parahaenolyticus densities in northern Gulf of Mexico water and Oysters. Applied Environment Microbiology 37: 7589-7596 .
  21. Omenwa VC, Ansa EJ, Agokie OE, Uka A, George OS (2011) Microbiological quality of raw and processed farm reach periwinkles from brackish water earth ponds, Buguma, Nigeria. African Journal of Foods Agricultural nutrition and Developments 11: 4623 4632 .
  22. Winfield MD, Groisman, EA (2003) Role of non-host environment in the life styles of Salmonella and Escheria coli. Applied and environmental Microbiology 69: 687-694 .
  23. Adebayo – Tayo BC, Okpo MA (2010) Microbiological, proximate and heavy metal; concentration in Penaeus Sp and callinectes sp. from creeks in Niger Delta. Africa. Journal of Food Agriculture Nutrition and Development 10: 30473064 .
  24. Odu NN, Njoku HO, Mepba HD (2012) Microbiological quality of smoke- dried mangrove oysters (Crassostrea gasar) sold in Port Harcourt, Nigeria. Agric Biol J N Am 3: 360-364 .
  25. Okonko IO, Ogun AA, Adejoye OD, Ogunjobi AA, Nkang AO Adebayo-Tayo BC (2009) Hazards analysis critical control points (HACCP) and Microbiology qualities of Sea-foods as affected by Handle’s Hygiene in Ibadan and Lagos, Nigeria. African Journal of Food Sciences 3: 35-50 .
  26. Helena M Solo-Gabriele, Melinda A Wolfert, Timothy R Desmarais, Carol J Palmer (2000) Sources of E. coli in a coastal subtropical environment. Appl. Environ. Microbio, 66: 230-237 .
  27. Odokuma LO, Okpokwasili GC (1992) Role of composition in degradation of oil spill dispersants. Waste Management 17: 39-43 .
  28. Beg MU, Saceed, T Al-Muzaini S, Beg KR, Al-Bahloul M (2003) Distribution of petroleum hydrocarbon in sediment from coastal area receiving industrial effluent in Kuwait. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 54:47–55 .
  29. Okpokwasili GC, Nunbia C (1995) Effects of oil spill dispersants and drilling fluids on substrate specificity of marine bacteria. Waste Management 15: 515-520 .
  30. Chikere BO, Okpokwasili GC (2004) Frequent occurrence of microorganisms at an effluent outfall site. Journal of Tropical Bioscience 4: 12-18.
  31. Fracundo JMR, Vanessa HR, Teresa ML (2001) Biodegradation of diesel in soil by a microbial consortium. Water Air Soil Pollut 128: 313-320 .
  32. Mourino-Perez RR, Wonder AZ, Azam F (2003) Growth of Vibrio cholera in red tide waters off Califonia. Applied Environmental Microbiology 69: 6923-6931 .
  33. Adebayo-Tayo BC, Onilude AA, Ogunjobi AA, Adeboye DO (2006) Bacteriology and proximate analysis of periwinkle from two different creeks in Nigeria. World Applied Science Journal 1: 87-91 .
  34. Njoku OE, Agwa OK, Ibiene AA (2015) An investigation of the microbiological and physicochemical profile of some fish pond water within the Niger delta region of Nigeria. African Journal of food Science 9: 155-162 .
  35. Makinde OO, Edun OM, Akinrotimi OA (2015) Comparative Assessment of Physical and Chemical characteristics of Water in Ekerekana and Buguma Creeks, Niger Delta Nigeria. Journal of Environment Protection and Sustainable Development 1: 126-133 .
  36. Eduok SI, Ebong GA, Udoinyang EP, Njoku JN, Eyen EA (2010) Bacteriological and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon accumulation in mangrove oyster from Douglas creek, Nigeria. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition 9: 35-42 .
  37. Chikere CB, Okpokwasili GC, Ichiakor O (2009) Characterization of hydrocarbon utilizing bacteria in tropical marine sediments. African Journal of Biotechnology 8: 2541-2544 .
© 2016 Edun OM, et al. This is an open-pjestcess article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.