Evaluation of balanced fertilizer types on yield and yield components of sorghum and validation of soil fertility map based fertilizer recommendation

Sorghum (sorghum bicolor l.) belonging to the family panacea, it is produced in many countries of the world and the fi fth major cereal crop in the world in terms of tonnage after maize, wheat, rice and barley [2]. It is the third most important cereal crop in Ethiopia and forth in southern region in terms of area of production [3]. In Ethiopia, it is adapted to a wide range of environments, and hence can be produced in the high lands, medium altitude and low lands. Sorghum is widely produced more than any other crops in the areas where there is moisture stress [4]. It is a staple food crop on which the lives of millions of poor Ethiopians depend. It has tremendous uses for the Ethiopian farmer and no part of this plant is ignored [5]. Sorghum is used in various ways in our country; the grain is used for human foods such as injera, bread, porridge, nifro, infant food, syrup, and local beverage known as “tella” and “arekie.” And also, the leaf and stalk are used for animal feed, Abstract

and further, the stalks are used for the construction of houses and fences and as fuel-wood.
However, the productivity(both grain and biomass yield) of sorghum is low; in Harari region, the average productivity of 22.22 quintal ha -1 which is even below the national average yield and productivity of 27.26 quintal ha -1 [2,6]. Soil fertility decline is the main issue in African agriculture in general and in Ethiopia in particular. In Ethiopia, large number of population is hardly satisfi ed by reliable production, instead a decline in their crop yield is letting them to suffer from poverty and malnutrition. Studies indicated that in some parts of Ethiopia farmer suffer from lack of what to eat particularly in months starting from June up to September (Abera, 2003). Ethiopian soils have been subjected to severe degradation caused by natural and man-made factors [7]. Low soil fertility and shortage of moisture is the major constraints in the reduction of growth and productivity of sorghum [8]. The rate of soil fertility decline depends on soil erosion, nutrient removal in harvests, the rate at which nutrients are returned to the soil through the use of both inorganic fertilizer and organic manures, and the rate of mineralization of soil mineral and organic matter nutrients [9]. fertilizer for sorghum production could make an important contribution to optimize profi t through increasing production and productivity of sorghum in areas, where there is low practice of using improved technologies such as optimum level of fertilizer [10]. Not only phosphorus and nitrogen in form of dap and urea, application of potassium, sulfur and zinc in different parts of the country sharply increase yield which leads the country started using fertilizers which can supply the defi cient nutrients and will continue to use in the form of blends /balanced [6].
Application of balanced fertilizer based on the actual limitation of nutrients in the soil is very crucial to increase production and productivity of crops. Balanced fertilizer amended with enough amount of nitrogen and phosphorous on sorghum gave the highest yield, nutritional content and economic return [11]. Moreover, application of macronutrients in combination with micronutrient increased sorghum yield and concomitantly improved n, p and k uptake and its nutrient use effi ciency of sorghum varieties [12]. Now a day, Agricultural Transformation Agency (ATA), has been conducted soil fertility survey and display it on the map. And also recommend different balanced fertilizer based on their map which is blanket recommendation. Thus why, those balanced fertilizer has to be checked and validated before going for calibration.
And also, increasing yields through the application of nitrogen and phosphorus alone can deplete other nutrients. Therefore, information on production practices to optimize the grain yield and quality of sorghum by applying the appropriate type of balanced fertilizer is important to sorghum production in Ethiopia in general and Kile kebele specifi cally. Hence. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of different balanced fertilizers in smallholder sorghum crop based farming systems in Sofi district, kile kebele of Harar regional state. Hence. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of balanced fertilizers and application rate in smallholder sorghum crop based farming systems in Kile kebele, Harari regional state.

Material and methods
The study was conducted during 2018 and 2019 main cropping season in Kile kebele Sofi woreda of Harari Regional state. Soil of study area was sandy clay loam. The annual average rainfall of the woreda ranges between to mm. The minimum and maximum annual temperature of 26 and 20 0 C > respectively. Rainfall of the woreda is bimodal, small rains start in March to April interrupted by drought whereas; the second rain starts at July and ends at October with very big variations in distributions and amount. The study area has diversity of climate, soil, and land forms. The topography of the woreda includes mountains, hills, uplands and lowland plains. The altitude ranges 1200 -1300 meter above sea level.

Experimental design and treatments
The experiment was laid out in Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with three replication of each treatment. There was three block in the experimental fi eld .Totally there were18 plots occupied by six treatments, since each treatment was replicated three times.. The space between block was 1.5m and space between plots was 0.5m.The experimental site was ploughed and harrowed before sowing. The improved and moisture stress resistant Melkam sorghum variety was used for the experiment. Plot size was 3m x 4m. Furrow rows were made manually in spacing of 75 cm apart and sorghum seed was drilled manually and thinned by 20cm spacing between plants. Those fertilizer treatments was differ in their nutrient composition. For example NPS differ from NPSzn by their nutrient composition (chemical formula), NPS consists, Nitrogen, phosphorous and sulfur in one pack (19 N -38 P2O5 +7S) and NPSzn (17.7 N -35.3 P2O5 + 6.5S + 2.5 Zn) contains, Nitrogen, phosphorous, sulfur and Zink nutrients in one pack and NPSB (18. 1 N -36.1 P2O5 + 6.7S + 0.71B).

Data collection and soil sampling
Treatment effects were determined by collecting plant height, panicle length, panicle diameter above ground biomass, and grain yield datas. Plant height was measured using meter tape (since malkam sorghum variety was short in height and simple to measure plant height, it was low land variety. Composite soil sample was collected from (0-20 cm) depth by diagonal rule or zigzag method with the sampling depth of (0-20) cm, Soil sample after harvest were collected from every plot (from 5 spots /auger points) and analyzed for soil physicochemical properties.

Data analysis
Analysis of variance was performed using the GLM procedure of SAS Statistical Software Version 9.1. Means were separated using Least Signifi cant Difference (LSD) test.
Response variable variables were, gain yield, biomass yield, panicle length and panicle diameter.

Economic analysis for balanced fertilizer
The dominance analysis procedure, which was used to select potentially profi table treatments, a dominance analysis is thus carried out by fi rst listing the treatments in order of increasing costs that vary. Any treatment that has net benefi ts that are less than or equal to those of a treatment with lower costs that vary is dominated. The selected treatments by using this technique were referred to as dominated treatments. For each pair of ranked un dominated treatments, a percentage marginal rate of return (% MRR) was calculated. The percent MRR between any pair of dominated treatments denoted the return per unit of investment in crop management practices expressed as percentage. The MRR (%) was calculated as follows [1]. For a treatment to be considered a worthwhile option to farmers, the marginal rate of return (MRR) needed to be at least 100%. Thus, the minimum acceptable rate of return was considered to be 100%.Partial budget analysis was used for economic balanced fertilizer analysis by considering the general relationship between the types of balanced fertilizer and sorghum yield per hectare of land. Total revenue, total variable cost, total fi xed cost, total cost, net income and benefi t cost ratio, of each treatment were analyzed by partial budget analysis based on CIMMYT procedure [1]. The data used for economic analysis were fi xed cost and variable cost.

Soil analysis
The textural class of the experimental soil was found to be sandy clay loam with the pH of 6.83-7.46, which is slightly alkaline and it is a preferred range for most crops (Table 1).
Total nitrogen content was 0.045-0.078%, which is within the range of very low levels (0.02-0.5%) for tropical soils.
The organic matter content of the soil was 1.68-2.62%, which is within a range of low (0.5-2%) for Ethiopian soils as per criteria developed by Murphy (1968) [13]. The available P content of the experimental soil was 2.39-3.39ppm that lies in a range of defi ciency (< 20-40mg/kg) for most crops (Landon, 1991). And available K (ppm) was very limiting when compared to the standard [13].

Plant height
Statistically there was highly signifi cant difference among the treatment at 5%. Level of confi dence. The highest plant height (156.6 cm) was recorded from treatment which receives 100 kgha -1 of NPSzn, but this was in statistical parity with rest treatments except control treatment. and the lowest plant height (147 cm) was measured from the control treatment. This is because of soil macro and micro nutrients defi ciency at kile PA's. Especially Zink and sulfur were the most defi cient nutrients there. This fi nding is in agreement with the report of Gebrekirkos, et al. [11], that plant height increases with increment of fertilizer application from nil to balanced fertilizer type including NPSzn. Furthermore, Redai, et al. 2018 [12] reported that application of NPSzn gives the highest plant height over the absolute control treatment. In addition to this, it can be suggested the application of optimum fertilizer nutrients increased the plant growth and biomass and the increased amounts of nutrient increases the production of sorghum [14].

Panicle length (kg/ha)
The longest panicle length (30.33 cm) was recorded from treatment that receives 120 Kg ha -1 NPSzn, but this was in statistical parity with the rest treatment except control while the lowest panicle length (27 cm) was recorded from the control treatment. The result was in conformity with the fi nding reported that tallest panicle length was recorded from the plot treated by blend fertilizer and the shortest panicle length was recorded from the control [12]. The current result was agree with increasing trend in blended fertilizer and amended with N and P in case of (NPSZn) fertilizer shows a corresponding increment of panicle length as compared with the nil fertilizers [11]. The current fi nding was disagree with fi nding reported that panicle length of sorghum did not give signifi cantly different response under fertilized and unfertilized conditions [15].

Biomass (kg/ha)
Biomass yield is an important output as farmers are also interested in it for animal feed and use as fuel wood in addition to grain yield. The highest above ground biomass (11666 kgha -1 ) was recorded from the treatment that receives 100 kgha -1 NPSZn and followed by NPSZnB; whereas the lowest above ground biomass (6389 kgha -1 ) was measured from treatments which receive 100 kgha -1 NPS this was in statistical parity with control and treatments that receive 100 kg/ha DAP and 60 kg/ha Urea . The result is in line with the fi nding of  reported that the highest biomass yield of sorghum was obtained from the application of blended fertilizer amended with NPSZn which was statistically at parity with the application of balanced fertilizer NPSZn. In contrary, the lowest above ground biomass was obtained from the nil fertilizer plots. Similar fi nding was reported by Berhane, et al.
[16] as application of high nitrogen level results in high amount of biomass yield in sorghum. The current fi nding was agree with the report plots treated by blend fertilizer gives highest biomass yield over the control plot as the lowest biomass yield was obtained [12].

Grain yield (kg/ha)
The highest grain yield (5200 kgha -1 ) was recorded from the treatment that receives 100 kgha -1 NPSZn followed by NPSZnB. This is because of soil macro and micro nutrients defi ciency at kile PA's is compensated by balanced fertilizer. Especially Zn and sulfur were the most defi cient nutrients [17]. Whereas the lowest grain yield (2548 kgha -1 ) was measured from control treatment ( Table 2). The current fi nding was agree with fi nding reported as the plots treated by NPSZn fertilizer gives highest grain yield as that of NPKSZn and the lowest grain yield of sorghum was recorded from control [12]. Similarly, Gebrekorkos, et al. [11] reported that the maximum grain yield was obtained from the balanced fertilizer types NPSZn, while the lowest yield was obtained in unfertilized plots. Additionally, the fi nding reported that increasing application of fertilizer nutrients such as N, P, K and Zn increases the grain yield and biomass weight of sorghum signifi cantly (Regessa, 2005).
Additionally, the result was agreed with the fi nding reported as sorghum yield increase with increase in the rate of nitrogen and application of blended fertilizer to the optimum rate [18][19][20][21].

Economic analysis
The economic evaluation and comprising partial budget analysis with dominance, and marginal rate of return was carried out. To estimate economic parameters, the yield of sorghum was valued based on average market price collected from the local markets during two consecutive years of production. The average cost of urea, NPS, NPSB, NPSZn, NPSZnB, and DAP 9.6 and birr per kg respectively. A wage rate of 75 birr a man per day was considered. Some of the concepts used in the partial budget analysis are gross fi eld benefi t (GFB), total variable cost (TVC), TFC and the net benefi t (NB) [1].

Effect of balanced fertilizer on economic sorghum productivity
Data concerning to economic comparison was presented in Table 3. The detail evaluation of the economic analysis of fertilizer treatments was shows that, as a result, the direct impact of balanced fertilizer (NPSZn) in generating NI was very high for a hectare of land per season which means good value from hectare than absolute control. Maximum total cost (7666ETB) was obtained by NPSZnB treatment whereas the minimum variable cost (5746ETB) was obtained by T1 (control). Benefi t cost ratio (BCR) of each treatment was computed as the ratio of NI earned to the TC expended. Accordingly, maximum BCR (5.1) were obtained by T4 means that treatment which receives NPSZn fertilizer. However, the lower BCR was recorded by T1 and T8. This implies that even though maximum yield was obtained by those treatments they were economically not more attractive. From this economic analysis the application, T4 (NPSZn)) was the most economically attractive treatment with high BCR and optimum net benefi t.
The marginal rate of return above 100% is high and acceptable to farmers (CIMMYT, 1988).With the acceptable marginal rate of return (MRR), NPSZn application was produced the highest net benefi ts and marginal rate of return as compared to absolute control and DAP and Urea. Therefore, farmers in the study area were benefi ted when they apply

Conclusion and Recommendation
The for animal feed and use as fuel wood in addition to grain yield.
The highest above ground biomass (11666 kgha -1 ) was recorded from the treatment that receives 100 kgha -1 NPSZn and followed by NPSZnB; whereas the lowest above ground biomass (6389 kgha -1 ) was measured from treatments which receive 100 kgha -1 NPS.Therfore, to get the highest, above ground biomass, farmers should apply NPSZn fertilizer. The highest grain yield (5200 kgha -1 ) was recorded from the treatment that receives 100kgha -1 NPSZn followed by NPSZnB.whereas the lowest grain yield (2548 kgha -1 ) was measured from control treatment (table   2). Using soil test based recommended balanced fertilizer type is economically profi table. The ATA recommendation of NPSZn for kile PA, of Harari regional state is valid for a given specifi c location.

Recommendation
Farmers should use fertilizer during the sowing season.